Arizona Geological History: Chapter 2, Cambrian and Ordovician Time

Tropical Oceanfront Property Available, but then there is an ice age.

In Chapter 1, the Precambrian, Arizona was at the South Pole and had just emerged from the sea. Plate tectonic movement was carrying what would be North America northward, and by Cambrian time (542- to 488 million years ago), North America spanned the equator. But the orientation was 90 degrees clockwise from it current setting so that the equator ran from Mexico through Canada.

 Paleomap 514

As time progressed, the continent rotated counterclockwise, and by Ordovician time (488- to 444 million years ago), the equator traced from near Washington State to Greenland. See a geologic time scale here.

By the way, positions of the continents are inferred from paleomagnetic studies and correlation of rock formations. Magnetic minerals in igneous rocks are oriented parallel to the magnetic lines of force on the planet at the time the rocks solidified, and thus point toward the position of the magnetic poles at that time. By 1950, accumulated magnetic data from all the continents appeared to show that the magnetic poles were wandering around the globe. But the apparent position of the poles at any given time was different as measured on different continents. Geophysicists finally concluded that the poles were not moving; the continents were.

In the following, I will describe the geological interpretation as if Arizona were in its current orientation relative to the poles.

Tapeats sandstoneThe sandstones, shales, and limestones deposited during Cambrian and Ordovician time represent deposition on a continental shelf, near shore, and on dry land. Much of the deposition was in an inter-tidal environment. Deep sea was toward the west and the continent toward the east. The sequence of rocks suggest that sea level was rising and falling (or the continent was doing the same). The shoreline progressed across Arizona from west to east as sea level rose. In general the sandstones were deposited on the shore and in shallow water. They show cross-bedding that would form from sand dunes and near-shore reworking. The shales were deposited in deeper water, beyond the sands, and limestones in even deeper water. Apparently, the land emerged again at the end of Ordovician time and remained emergent during the subsequent Silurian Period (444- to 416 million years ago), since there are no rocks of Silurian age recognized in Arizona, but there are in New Mexico.

The position of the continent near the equator implies it was subject to trade winds. Some of the rocks hold evidence of major storms and erosion of islands of Precambrian rocks.

Tapeats worm burrows USGSIn northern Arizona, the basal Cambrian sandstone is called the Tapeats Sandstone. It was deposited on eroded Precambrian rocks and soil developed from those rocks. In southern Arizona the basal sandstone is called the Bolsa Quartzite. Above the basal sandstone is a series of shale, sandstone and carbonates (Bright Angel Shale north, Abrigo Formation south). These rocks are interpreted to represent mainly shallow water deposits and sand dunes, both of which were subject to scouring and erosion in a near-shore environment. The sequence is capped by limestone (Mauv Limestone north and El Paso limestone south) which means the western sea rose once again to cover Arizona. 

 Bolsa quartzite BensonCambrian time was when life became abundantly obvious. Invertebrate fossils include trilobites, mollusks, soft-bodied worms, jellyfish, and sponges. The Ordovician added corals, snails, clams, and the first vertebrates: fishes, as well as primitive terrestrial plant life. The development of terrestrial plants greatly reduced the rate of erosion. Marine fauna recycled the carbon contained in Precambrian algal mats.

Ordovician time ended with a major ice age, and extinction of about 20% of marine species. The Ordovician ice age occurred even though atmospheric carbon dioxide was more than 10 times the current concentration.

Principal references:

Middleton, L.T., 1989, Cambrian and Ordovician Depositional Systems in Arizona, In Geologic Evolution of Arizona, Arizona Geological Society Digest 17.

Hayes, P.L. 1978, Cambrian and Ordovician Rocks of Southeastern Arizona and Southwestern New Mexico, in New Mexico Geological Society Guidebook 29.

Advertisements

7 comments

  1. As always, very interesting stuff, Jonathan!
     
    I’ve always wondered just where the names for epochs came from and who decided them? Was there a lot of drinking involved in the process?

  2. Many of the names came from the early British geologists.  For instance, the name “Cambrian” refers to Cambria, the ancient name for Wales.  The Ordovician was named after the Ordovices,  an ancient British tribe in N Wales, where rocks characterizing the period were found.

  3. Yes, very interesting. This is starting to feel like the beginning of a James Michner book.
     
    Just a couple of questions. How do you know just how much atmospheric carbon dioxide was present in the Cambrian and Ordovician? And, if that much was indeed present how could there be an Ice Age? That scenario would seem to contradict everything that we are hearing about global warming today.

    1. Question 1: The evolution of the carbon cycle and of atmospheric CO2 over Phanerozoic time is based on a variety of geological, geochemical, biological, and climatological data.
       
      “On a multimillion year time scale the major process affecting atmospheric CO2 is exchange between the atmosphere and carbon stored in rocks. This long-term, or geochemical carbon cycle is distinguished from the more familiar short-term cycle that involves the transfer of carbon between the oceans, atmosphere, biosphere, and soils. In the long-term cycle loss of CO2 from the atmosphere is accomplished by photosynthesis and burial of organic matter in sediments and by the reaction of atmospheric CO2 with Ca and Mg silicates during continental weathering to form, ultimately, Ca and Mg carbonates on the ocean floor (after transport of the weathering-derived Ca, Mg, and carbon to the sea by rivers). Release of CO2 to the atmosphere in the long-term carbon cycle takes place via the oxidative weathering of old organic matter and by the thermal breakdown of buried carbonates and organic matter (via diagenesis, metamorphism and volcanism) resulting in degassing to the earth surface.”
      Read: Berner, R.A. and Kothavala, Z., 2001, GEOCARB III: A revised model of atmospheric CO2 over Phanerozoic time: Am. J. Sci., v. 301, p. 182-204,
       
      or: Rothman, D.H. 2002. Atmospheric carbon dioxide levels for the last 500 million years. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 99: 4167-4171.
       
      to see how they derive CO2 concentration from weathering rates.
       
      The geologic reconstruction of temperature is based on oxygen-18 isotopes from fossils and cave stalagmites.
       
      Question 2: Carbon dioxide has nothing to do with ice ages, see: Veizer, Jan, 2005, Celestial Climate Driver: A Perspective from Four Billion Years of the Carbon Cycle, Geoscience Canada, V. 32, no. 1
       
      Question 3: Yes, real science contradicts the phantom menace.

Comments are closed.